GV249 Seminar WT2: Controlling for Confounders

Lennard Metson

2025-02-04

Confounders

📖

Bueno de Mesquita & Fowler - Thinking Clearly with Data - Ch. 10

🔀 Confounders

What are some examples?

  • Age → Turnout
  • Democracy → Growth
  • News consumption → ideology
  • Contact → prejudice

🔀 Confounders

Controlling:

  • Isolates relationship between two variables from the correlations with the confounder → closer to the causal effect

Remaining limitations:

  • Unobserved, and unobservable, remaining confounders
  • Reverse causality

📈 Multiple Regression

\(Y = \alpha + \beta \cdot \text{Height} + \gamma \cdot \text{Gender} + \epsilon\)

📈 Multiple Regression 1: No control

\(Y = \alpha + \beta \cdot \text{Height} + \epsilon\)

📈 Multiple Regression 2: Add control

\(Y = \alpha + \beta \cdot \text{Height} + \gamma \cdot \text{Gender} + \epsilon\)

📈 Multiple Regression 2: Intercepts

📈 Multiple Regression 3: Visualising continuous controls

📈 Interpreting multiple regression

\(Y= \alpha + \beta_1 X_1 + \beta_2 X_2 + \epsilon\)

  • \(\alpha\): the intercept. Value of \(Y\) when all \(X\)’s = 0.
  • \(\beta_1\): regression coefficient for first variable (\(X_1\))
  • \(\beta_2\): regression coefficient for first variable (\(X_2\))
  • \(\epsilon\): the error term

📈 Prediction with multiple regression

\(\text{Turnout}= 0.32 + 0.02 \cdot \text{Age} + -0.04 \cdot \text{Gender}\)

  • Gender coded as 1 for women and 0 for men

Prediction time:

  • What is the predicted turnout rate for a 32 year old man?
  • What is the predicted turnout rate for a 0 year old woman?

📈 Reading multiple regression tables

Reference NPAT category = 1-20.

Predictions:

  • What is the predicted ACU rating for a Republican with an NPAT score in the 61-80 percentile?
  • What is the predicted ACU rating for a Democrat with an NPAT score in the 21-40 percentile?
  • What is the predicted ACU rating for a Democrat with an NPAT score of 14?

💻 Lab